There is a particular kind of clarity that comes from holding a gold coin in your hand. It is dense, surprisingly so — a one-ounce American Eagle carries a weight that seems disproportionate to its size. And in that weight, you can feel something that no digital asset, no paper certificate, no financial instrument can replicate: the tangible reality of stored value.
I've spent years studying markets, currencies, and the mechanisms by which wealth is created and destroyed. And after all that study, I keep returning to the same conclusion: physical gold ownership isn't just a hedge — it's a philosophical statement about the nature of money itself.
The Case Against Infinite Money
The fundamental problem with modern currency is that there is no natural limit to its creation. Since the final abandonment of the gold standard in 1971, the U.S. dollar — and by extension, most global currencies — has been backed by nothing more than institutional trust and government decree.
This isn't inherently catastrophic. Fiat systems can function well for extended periods. But they carry within them a structural temptation that has proven, historically, to be irresistible: the ability to create money from nothing to solve short-term political problems.
"Gold is money. Everything else is credit."
J.P. Morgan, testimony to Congress, 1912Consider the numbers. In 2020 alone, approximately 23% of all U.S. dollars in existence were created in a single year. The M2 money supply expanded from roughly $15.4 trillion to $19.1 trillion. This wasn't an aberration — it was an acceleration of a trend that has been building for decades.
Why Physical Over Paper
You can gain exposure to gold through ETFs, futures contracts, mining stocks, or digital gold platforms. Each has its uses. But none of them are gold.
An ETF share is a claim on gold held by a custodian, subject to counterparty risk, management decisions, and the solvency of the institutions involved. A futures contract is a promise. A mining stock is an equity in a company that happens to dig gold out of the ground, subject to management risk, regulatory risk, and operational risk that have nothing to do with the metal itself.
Physical gold has none of these dependencies. When you own a gold coin or bar, you own it in the most absolute sense that property ownership allows. There is no counterparty. There is no password to remember, no server to maintain, no institution that needs to remain solvent for your asset to retain its value.
The Practical Considerations
Owning physical gold does come with genuine trade-offs that should be acknowledged honestly:
- Storage — You need somewhere secure to keep it. A quality home safe costs $500-2,000. A bank safe deposit box runs $75-300 annually. Private vault storage varies but typically costs 0.5-1% of value per year.
- Liquidity — Selling physical gold is slower than selling an ETF. You'll need to find a dealer, and you'll face a spread between buy and sell prices, typically 3-5% for common bullion.
- No yield — Gold doesn't pay dividends or interest. It just sits there, being gold. This is either a bug or a feature, depending on your perspective.
- Premiums — You'll pay above spot price when buying. Government-minted coins carry premiums of 3-7% over spot; generic bars are typically 1-3% over spot.
For first-time buyers, we recommend American Gold Eagles or Canadian Gold Maple Leafs. They carry slightly higher premiums than generic bars, but they're universally recognized, easy to authenticate, and highly liquid when you need to sell.
Read Our Buying GuideWhat Gold Actually Does in a Portfolio
Gold's role in a portfolio isn't to generate returns — it's to reduce the impact of the things you can't predict. It's portfolio insurance that also happens to preserve purchasing power over very long time horizons.
During the 2008 financial crisis, while the S&P 500 fell 37%, gold rose 5.5%. During the COVID crash of March 2020, gold initially fell with everything else but recovered within weeks and went on to reach all-time highs. In the inflationary environment of 2022, gold held its value while both stocks and bonds declined simultaneously.
I'm not suggesting gold always goes up. It doesn't. It spent twenty years between 1980 and 2000 in a bear market, losing over 80% of its inflation-adjusted value. Gold is not a get-rich-quick scheme. It's not even a particularly exciting investment most of the time.
But it is the one asset that has maintained its purchasing power across millennia, across civilizations, across every political and economic system humanity has devised. An ounce of gold bought a fine toga in Roman times. Today, it buys a fine suit. That consistency over 2,000+ years is not a coincidence — it reflects something fundamental about gold's properties and humanity's relationship with scarcity.